Compare BlackBag, WeTransfer, Hightail

Same job.
Different promise.

All three move big files. Only one is built so the company running it can't open them. Here's how they line up, including where the others are ahead.

Security and privacy

Who can see what

BlackBagWeTransferHightail
EncryptionEnd-to-end, in the browser (AES-256-GCM)Zero knowledge: we never have the keyIn transit (TLS) and at rest (AES-256)WeTransfer controls the keysIn transit (TLS) and at rest (AES-256)Hightail manages the keys
Can the provider read your files?NoTechnically yesTechnically yes
Recipient checkOne-time email code on every download, every plan"Access control" on UltimateIdentity verification on paid plans
After deliveryDeleted right away, at midnight, or at expiry: your choiceTime-based expiry; paid plans can recover files up to 1 year afterExpiry on Lite; paid plans can keep files with no forced expiry
Sending and requesting

What you can move

BlackBagWeTransferHightail
Free plan, per transfer5 GB3 GB (10 transfers or 3 GB per 30 days)100 MB per file
Largest paid transfer100 GBNo cap on Ultimate500 GB on Business
Link lifetimeUp to 30 days on paid plans; 3 days free3 days on Free and Starter; up to 30 on Ultimate7 days on Lite; configurable on paid
File requestsEvery plan; sealed so only you can open themWith a free account; uploader verifies emailAdd-on for Pro; included in Teams and Business
Resume after a dropped uploadYes, from the last partNot statedNot stated
Integrity checkEvery 64 MiB part verified; tampering or truncation is refusedNot statedNot stated
Price

What it costs

BlackBagWeTransferHightail
Free$0$0$0 (Lite)
Entry paid plan$9/mo, or $90/yrPro: 100 GB transfers, 30-day links$10/mo, or $7/mo yearlyStarter$15/mo, or $12/mo yearlyPro: 25 GB per file
Big-file plan$9/mo (same Pro plan)$25/mo, or $19/mo yearlyUltimate$45/user/mo, or $36 yearlyBusiness, 3+ users
Teams$19/user/mo, or $190/yr$25/user/mo, or $19 yearly$30/user/mo, or $24 yearly

Where they're ahead, honestly

  • Bigger single files: WeTransfer Ultimate has no size cap and Hightail Business takes 500 GB. BlackBag tops out at 100 GB per transfer.
  • Deleted-file recovery: their paid plans can bring back expired files. We can't, because once a file is purged there is nothing left to recover.
  • Team admin, branding and integrations: both offer branded pages and team controls that BlackBag doesn't have yet.
  • Forgotten PIN: they can reset your access. We can't, because your PIN is part of the key.

Competitor details are from their public pricing and help pages, checked November 20, 2026. WeTransfer prices are from a third-party capture of its pricing page dated November 16, 2026. "Not stated" means we found no public claim either way. Plans change, so check their sites before deciding. WeTransfer and Hightail are trademarks of their owners; BlackBag isn't affiliated with either.